Turns out a quick 'n easy solution was to flip the spacer onto the other side. I don't have any tools to grind the spacer + screw down. Could I find a similar screw that'd fit at a hardware store?
Here's what it looks like now-
Final thoughts for anyone thinking of doing the 2.5 inch extension mod-
1. It was pretty easy to do on my own (if I can do it, anyone can)
2. You'll have to extend your break line (part included in the kit). So you'll have to re-bleed your rear break-line. I wasn't initially aware of this, but it's easy to do.
3. I'm 6" and the extended controls are a perfect fit. They feel great. Real glad I got 'em